A tavern-cut pizza intended to feed four adults exposed fundamental disagreements about distributive justice Tuesday when the first diner selected a large center square.

The group had agreed to divide the cost equally. It had not agreed whether this entitled each person to the same number of pieces, the same area of pizza, or a fair opportunity to obtain a piece before Mark.

“We’ll just go around,” said Emily Price, proposing a procedure that immediately favored the person sitting nearest the pizza and anyone able to distinguish a full square from a triangular edge in low lighting.

Mark defended his first selection on the grounds that he had ordered. Emily replied that ordering had consisted of saying the name of a pizza everyone had already chosen. This briefly shifted the discussion from fairness to the nature of labor.

A third diner offered to take the small corner pieces because she liked the crust. Everyone agreed this would help, until Mark noticed she was getting exactly what she wanted.

Emily proposed dividing by surface area. Mark pointed out that some squares had three pieces of sausage and some had none. Emily asked whether he intended to count the sausage. He said he had already started.

The fourth diner asked whether anyone minded if he ate while they worked this out. Nobody objected, establishing a precedent Mark would later cite.

By the time the group agreed that people should take whatever they wanted, the most desirable pieces were gone. The remaining arrangement was described as fair enough.

They ordered a second pizza. Emily asked the server whether it could be cut into four.

The server said yes. For reasons nobody could adequately explain, this felt wrong.